What is known
In a previous editorial “Testosterone and Prostate Cancer - a paradigm shift” we explained why the relation between testosterone and prostate cancer is not linear and we have also presented studies investigating whether testosterone therapy increases risk of prostate cancer in men with no history of prostate issues, see “Dispelling the myth of testosterone treatment and prostate cancer”
Briefly, even large elevations in testosterone levels within the normal range will only cause minor increases (if any) in PSA, and testosterone therapy does not increase prostate cancer incidence or BPH/LUTS progression compared to matched untreated men.6 The explanation for this is the saturation model, which postulates that within the normal range of testosterone levels, prostate cells are saturated to the stimulating effect of androgens that is seen at hypogonadal testosterone levels, and therefore unresponsive to further increases in testosterone concentration. In other words, testosterone exerts its maximal effect on androgen receptors and prostate cancer growth at low concentrations while having little to no impact at higher concentrations.7 The saturation model also explains why an initial increase in PSA in hypogonadal men who start testosterone therapy does not necessarily (more precisely, rarely) reflect prostate disease progression.
Recent studies on testosterone therapy in men with a history of prostate cancer
Over the last two decades a growing number of studies have shown provocative results, questioning the deeply rooted long held view that testosterone therapy is an absolute contraindication in men with a history of prostate cancer.
The most common treatments for prostate cancer are radical prostatectomy (surgical removal of the prostate gland), radiation and brachytherapy (insertion of radioactive implants directly into the prostate tissue).
Testosterone therapy after radical prostatectomy
Several studies examining testosterone therapy in hypogonadal men who have been treated with prostatectomy found no PSA recurrence 8-12 and no biochemical or clinical evidence of prostate cancer recurrence.10 In one prospective study, only 1 of 22 men had a PSA recurrence at 17 months after radical prostatectomy. He had high-risk prostate cancer (Gleason score 8), and was on transdermal testosterone for 12 months at time of PSA elevation.13 This study concluded that when patients are carefully selected (Gleason score <7, organ confined disease, at least 2 PSA levels undetectable, 7-year Progression free probability, PFP > 90%) testosterone therapy for the treatment of hypogonadal symptoms appears to be safe at 2 years post-T administration.13
In a notable study, 103 hypogonadal men treated with testosterone were compared with 49 non-hypogonadal men with low-, intermediate-, and high-risk prostate cancer; all men were treated with prostatectomy.14 After a median follow-up of 27.5 months, testosterone levels significantly increased in the testosterone treatment group. A statistically, albeit not clinically, significant increase in PSA was observed in the high-risk and low-risk subgroups.
To better understand whether the observed PSA increases in men on testosterone were indicative of prostate cancer recurrence, PSA velocity was calculated. Despite the small PSA increases in men on testosterone, PSA velocities were not supportive of prostate cancer growth or recurrence in these men.14 Notably, there were twice as many prostate cancer recurrences among high-risk men who were not on testosterone therapy, compared to high-risk men who were treated with testosterone (8 vs. 4, respectively).14 No prostate cancer recurrence was observed in the low- or intermediate-risk subgroups.14
Testosterone therapy after radiation
Studies examining testosterone therapy in patients who had been treated for prostate cancer with radiotherapy have shown either no or small increases in PSA, largely in the absence of prostate cancer progression or recurrence.12,15-18 One study with long-acting testosterone undecanoate injections in 20 men (age 49-74 years) with prostate cancer treated with brachytherapy found no cases of rising serum PSA, prostate cancer progression or recurrence after a median of 31-months follow-up, and resulted in significant clinical benefits.18 A retrospective analysis of clinical records on testosterone therapy in 98 older hypogonadal men (age 63-74 years) with prostate cancer treated with radiation therapy found no increase in PSA in men with low- or medium-risk prostate cancer, but a small statistically significant increase in PSA in the high-risk subgroup. Only six men (6.1%) met criteria for biochemical recurrence.19
Testosterone therapy in men on active surveillance
Active surveillance is a strategy of close monitoring for men with low-risk prostate cancer. The purpose of active surveillance is to avert treatment unless prostate cancer progression occurs, or a patient chooses curative treatment.20 One third of men on active surveillance have testosterone deficiency 21, which is about the same prevalence as that seen in the general male population.22
While only a few studies are available on the effect of testosterone therapy in men with low-risk prostate cancer on surveillance, data are promising. In one study, 13 symptomatic testosterone deficient men with untreated prostate cancer received testosterone therapy for a median of 2.5 years (range 1 to 8 years). Mean age was 58.8 years. Gleason score at initial biopsy was 6 in 12 men and 7 in 1. Testosterone levels increased from 8.3 nmol/L to 23 nmol/L (p <0.001). Mean PSA and prostate volume did not change with testosterone therapy. Mean number of follow-up biopsies was 2. No cancer was found in 54% of follow-up biopsies. Biopsies in 2 men suggested upgrading, and subsequent biopsies in 1 and radical prostatectomy in another indicated no progression. No local prostate cancer progression or distant disease was observed.22
In another study, 28 men with testosterone deficiency underwent testosterone therapy while on active surveillance for prostate cancer (Gleason 3 + 3 and Gleason 3 + 4). A comparison group of 96 men on active surveillance with untreated testosterone deficiency was identified at the same institution.23 Mean age was 60 years, and mean follow-up 40 months for both groups. Biopsy progression rates were similar for both groups, as well as for historical controls. 23 It was concluded that biopsy progression in men on active surveillance appears unaffected by testosterone therapy over 3 years.23
The most recent study used prostate magnetic resonance imaging – a technology to improve detection, localisation, and cancer risk stratification - to examine 12 men treated with testosterone therapy while on active surveillance for low-risk prostate cancer.24 After testosterone therapy there was a significant increase in testosterone levels from 7 nmol/L to 17.9 nmol/L, PSA (3.3 ng/mL to 4.2ng/mL), and prostate volume (39.4 cm3 to 55.2 cm3). Of the 12 subjects, 2 had prostate cancer progression (detected by biopsy). Of these 2 patients, 1 patient underwent radical treatment due to clinical progression. The other 10 men had no changes in either prostate biopsy or prostate magnetic resonance imaging parameters after testosterone therapy. 24
It should be noted that responses to testosterone therapy in men with active low-grade prostate cancer is variable. Some men have little change in PSA velocity (a criterion to discontinue testosterone therapy) after years of treatment, while others have a rapid and significant increase. Nevertheless, interruption of testosterone therapy always has been found to lead to a decrease in PSA to baseline levels seen before initiation of testosterone therapy.25 This should encourage consideration of testosterone therapy in these men, as no irreversible potentially damaging changes are incurred that would cause permanent elevations in PSA levels.
In a survey of Canadian urologists who actively prescribe testosterone therapy and are involved in the treatment of prostate cancer, only 35% of the surveyed physicians had ever offered testosterone for men on active surveillance.26 This underscores the need for further continuing medical education in this area.
What this study adds
A recent study published in the Journal of Urology analyzed a group of 82 hypogonadal men (age 70 to 82 years at last follow-up) with prostate cancer who were treated with testosterone therapy.5 Included were 50 men treated with radiation therapy, 22 treated with radical prostatectomy, 8 on active surveillance, 1 treated with cryotherapy and 1 who underwent high intensity focused ultrasound. Testosterone therapy duration ranged between 22 to 57 months.
In the entire group, an increase in testosterone (p <0.001) and prostate specific antigen (p = 0.001) was found. However, no men on active surveillance were upgraded to a higher Gleason score on subsequent biopsies and none have yet gone on to definitive treatment.5 No biochemical prostate cancer recurrence was found among patients treated with radical prostatectomy, but 3 men (6%) treated with radiation therapy experienced biochemical recurrence. It is unclear whether these cases were related to testosterone therapy or reflected the natural biology of the disease.5 Mean PSA velocity was 0.001, 0.12 and 1.1 µg/L per year in the radical prostatectomy, radiation therapy and active surveillance groups, respectively.
This study concluded that testosterone therapy may be oncologically safe in hypogonadal men who have had curative treatment for prostate cancer, and in men on active surveillance for prostate cancer.5
The significant impact that hypogonadism has on quality of life and the need to treat a growing population of men, many of whom will have prostate cancer during their lives, raises the question of whether testosterone therapy can be considered in men with prostate cancer.
A history of prostate cancer has been a longstanding contraindication to the use of testosterone therapy due to the belief that higher serum testosterone causes more rapid prostate cancer growth. Recent evidence has called this belief into question by showing that testosterone therapy does not appear to cause prostate cancer recurrence in men who have been treated for prostate cancer. Early data also suggest that testosterone does not cause prostate cancer progression in men with active low-grade prostate cancer. These findings challenge a medical maxim that dates back 75 years 2, and currently there is insufficient evidence to withhold testosterone therapy in certain populations of men with a history of prostate cancer.27
Testosterone therapy in hypogonadal men with a treated prostate cancer results in significant elevations in testosterone levels and improvements in hypogonadal symptoms.9,14,16-18 Needless to say, despite the reassuring new findings in terms of safety and efficacy, men with low-grade or treated prostate cancer need extra vigilant monitoring if put on testosterone therapy.